Lily's Handmade Ice Cream menu

Milkshake (16 Oz)

3 scoops of ice cream of your choice, drizzle and whipped cream.

Kinderella- Pint

A chocolate-hazelnut fantasy. This creamy Nutella®-based ice cream is packed with chunks of Kinder Bueno® and rich fudgy brownies for the perfect mix of crunchy, gooey, and ultra-smooth. Pure indulgence in every scoop.

Dusty Monkey- Pint

A fan favorite. This creamy, fresh-banana ice cream is infused with crushed Biscoff® cookies and packed with even more Biscoff® chunks throughout. Smooth, crunchy, and unbelievably addictive — the perfect banana-cookie combo.

Double Espresso- Pint

Bold, creamy, and made for coffee lovers. This rich espresso ice cream delivers a smooth, intense coffee flavor with a double hit of real espresso. Deep, energizing, and perfectly balanced.

Cookie Chaos- Pint

A cookie lover’s dream. This creamy chocolate chip cookie flavored ice cream is packed with chunks of cookie dough and extra chocolate chips for the perfect mix of soft, chewy, and crunchy. Every scoop is loaded with chaos in the best possible way.

Soflo Swamp- Pint

A chocolate lover’s dream with a wild twist. This rich Belgian chocolate ice cream is infused with crushed Oreo® cookies and loaded with extra Oreo® chunks and chocolate chips in every scoop. Thick, crunchy, and ultra-chocolatey — a swamp you’ll want to dive into.

Cookies & Cream Supreme- Pint

Our ultimate cookies & cream experience. A rich Oreo®-based ice cream loaded with big, crunchy Oreo® chunks in every scoop. Extra creamy, extra cookie-packed, and seriously addictive.

Mint Chocolate Chunk- Pint

Naturally colored, refreshingly smooth, and loaded with flavor. This creamy mint ice cream is packed with real Andes mint pieces and rich chocolate chips for the perfect cool, chocolatey crunch in every bite. Crisp, creamy, and unbelievably satisfying.

Belgian Chocolate- Pint

Deep, rich, and ultra smooth. Our Belgian Chocolate is made in small batches with real imported Belgian cocoa & Chocolate for a bold, velvety flavor. This chocolate lover’s favorite delivers pure indulgence in every scoop.

Pure Vanilla- Pint

Rich, creamy, and made the Lily’s way. Our Pure Vanilla is crafted in small batches using real vanilla and our signature handmade base from Delray. Smooth, silky, and naturally flavorful.

Strawberry Dream- Pint

Bright, fresh, and naturally sweet. This creamy ice cream is made with real strawberries for a smooth, refreshing burst of flavor in every scoop. Light, fruity, and perfectly dreamy.

Blockbuster

2 Scoops of Kinderella (Nutella, brownies & kinder Bueno) Ice cream, M&m’s, Reese’s Pieces, Hot fudge & Whipped cream.

Arctic Mint Bliss

2 Scoops of Mint Chocolate Chunk & Belgian Chocolate, Andes Mints, Chocolate chips, Hot Fudge & Whipped cream.

Worms & Dirt

2 Scoops of Vanilla ice cream, Oreo Cookies, Gummy Worms, Hot Fudge & Whipped cream.

Nutty Nana

2 Scoops of Dusty Monkey(Banana base with biscoff), Reese’s Pieces, Peanut Butter cups, Hot Fudge & Whipped Cream.

Gator Tracks

2 Scoops of Cookies & cream supreme and Soflo swamp(Belgian Chocolate with Oreos & Chocolate chips), Chocolate Chips, Oreo Cookies, Hot fudge & Whipped cream.

The OG

2 Scoops of Vanilla ice cream, Roasted Peanuts, Rainbow Sprinkles, Hot Fudge & Whipped Cream.

Coffee Lovers

2 scoops of Double Espresso, Chocolate chips, Chocolate sprinkles, Hot fudge & Whipped cream.

Giant Oreo Sandwich(4 Pack)

Ultimate Peanut Butter- Pint

A peanut lover’s dream. Thick, creamy peanut butter ice cream loaded with Jif, Reese’s Pieces, and rich peanut butter cups in every scoop. Sweet, salty, crunchy, and ultra-smooth — this is the ultimate peanut butter experience, handcrafted to perfection.

Peppermint Stick- Pint

A silky smooth peppermint ice cream base made with natural color, blended with refreshing crushed peppermint candies. Cool, creamy, and perfectly balanced with a festive minty crunch. A handcrafted seasonal favorite that’s rich, refreshing, and impossible to resist.

Peppermint Stick 6oz Scoop

A silky smooth peppermint ice cream base made with natural color, blended with refreshing crushed peppermint candies. Cool, creamy, and perfectly balanced with a festive minty crunch. A handcrafted seasonal favorite that’s rich, refreshing, and impossible to resist.

Ultimate Peanut Butter 6oz Scoop

A peanut lover’s dream. Thick, creamy peanut butter ice cream loaded with Jif, Reese’s Pieces, and rich peanut butter cups in every scoop. Sweet, salty, crunchy, and ultra-smooth , this is the ultimate peanut butter experience, handcrafted to perfection.

Belgian Waffle Sundae

Whole Belgian waffle, Three scoops of ice cream, Two candy topping, hot fudge, whipped cream.

Brownie Blast

2 scoops of ice cream layered with brownies, topped with hot fudge and whipped cream.

Banana Split

Banana, Three scoops of ice cream, one candy topping, hot fudge and whipped cream.

Classic( 1 Scoop) 6oz

Double Delight (2 Scoops) 8oz

Kids (4oz)

Big Dipper(3 Scoops) 12oz

Classic Chocolate Chip

scoop of ice cream between 2 Chocolate Chip Cookies

Giant Oreo Ice Cream Sandwich

scoop of ice cream with two 3" Oreo wafers.